In my” Anatomy of” series I go in detail and cover the idea and parts behind a computer customized for a very specific era of gaming. I usually see the topic of what is best for this or that in DOS machines. The DOS era covers a HUGE area of computer history and to be able to reliably experience all those games to there optimum visuals and sound there’s really no one best setup. I do realize that many people either don’t have the space or care to have multiple PC’s for every specific era of DOS gaming so I’ve decided to briefly explain what I would feel makes up the best all around DOS machine. This machine may not be the fastest or produce the best sound but I think it will play the vast majority of DOS games thrown at it. If I could only have one DOS machine this would be it for its ability to play almost anything.
Operating System – For DOS the only choice is really DOS 6.22. There are a few games that will give you trouble if not played on a specific version of DOS but for the most part it’s the same but more options. Also most of the later DOS games that encompass a large amount of games will require at least DOS 5 or above. A lot of people would also recommend Windows 98SE as an operating system since you can enter “real DOS mode” (DOS 7) through it. This would let you play your DOS games as well as allow the playing of early windows games. This is a acceptable option but personally I still find pure DOS much simpler and less of a hassle but it really depends on what you want and how much effort your willing to put into it. having windows (even with its real DOS mode) is still going to cut down your DOS game options and probably create a lot of headaches getting things like sound to run in DOS. you’re also probably going to get a lot of memory manager errors with some games. My suggestion is just stick with DOS 6.22 unless your dead set on having Windows 98 games as well, aren’t concerned with the drop in DOS games that will be compatible and have time to deal with the errors and conflicts some DOS games will produce when run with Windows on the system. Keep in mind that the slower CPU/Video/RAM will hinder some of those later windows games.
CPU – Intel Pentium 100mhz – 133mhz. The Intel Pentiums are good performers, reliable and not to rare or expensive. Keeping it under 133mhz helps keep down a lot of the timing errors you’ll get playing a DOS games on a Pentium but still give you enough speed to competently play Duke 3D and Doom. I would use a 100mhz just to help keep the timing issues down but a P120 or 133 would also work as excellent CPU’s
Video card – S3 PCI Trio64/V2, Not the fastest video card out there but defiantly the most compatible. There’s a reason emulators like DOSBOX use the S3 line as their baseline for graphics. it’s basically the standard for DOS video and has excellent compatibility. You could also use any S3 Virge up to the Virge/GX card which supposedly uses the same excellent 2D core. Using a Virge card would also allow you to play any DOS S3D 3d accelerated games like Terminal Velocity or Tomb Raider
*adding a Voodoo 1 card would expand your choice of games to early DOS glide 3d games while keeping the excellent 2d compatibility of the Trio.
other choices for video card
PCI Tseng Labs 4000ET or 6000ET – any PCI card using a Tseng Labs chip should work fine. The Tseng Labs 4000ET was the king of DOS in the ISA and VLB days commonly seen as the fastest DOS card of the 486 era. Around when the PCI era started it seems to have lost a little of its edge. Still a great card but for later DOS games and slightly better compatibility go with a S3 card.
Ark Logic 2000MT – any card based on the ARK2000MT chip. very fast and compatible DOS card comparable to the ET4000
Sound – Creative Sound Blaster 16. The de facto sound standard for the DOS days. Most games support the SB standard and its adlib compatible. It wont give you the quality or range of the AWE series or the Gravis Ultrasound but you’ll get pretty decent sound and music in just about every game you throw at it.
*with a little extra cash and effort you can add a second sound card or an external sound module for expanded compatibility and quality in games that support the chosen card. This would be completely optional and would not interfere with the excellent compatibility of the SB16.
RAM – Most of those DOS games will happily run off 8MB of RAM but for the best compatibility and speed I would say 64MB and that’s still kinda overkill. You could go all out and do 128MB of RAM or even more but I’ve read unconfirmed rumors that some old DOS games/programs act a little unstable if there’s way more RAM than required/expected so I would stick to 64 or 128 at the most just to be safe. Besides if you have a BIOS that insists on doing a RAM check on startup it takes forever with huge amounts of RAM.
Those really are the main points, most motherboards should work just fine, just make sure it has a few ISA and PCI slots. type of RAM doesn’t matter too much either as long as it supports the amount you need. Other than that a nice hard drive of at least 500MB, a 3 1/2 floppy drive and a CD ROM drive and your set. also adding a 5 1/4 floppy drive will also help expand your range of games too much older titles or newer ones that you may find on that format. Again not the fanciest, fastest, best sounding or prettiest setup but in my opinion if you only want one DOS computer this will play the vast majority of games just fine and not cost an arm and a leg or several years part hunting.
I recently threw together a Pentium based DOS computer to experiment with some different hardware/software in DOS and I think it makes a pretty solid all around DOS PC with the potential to be upgraded or duel booted with Win 95/98 and thus makes a good example for an all around DOS PC.
Standard ATX case with a common 1.44MB floppy drive and a 1.2MB drive installed as well as a CD-ROM drive. You can use a DVD drive as well if you wish. It should function just like a CD drive.
*It’s not in the image above but I did recently install a Zip 100 drive under the floppy drive. It’s a really handy addition for files that are larger then 1.44MB but to small to justify burning CD or messing with a network. Its also nice that you can use a USB ZIP drive with windows XP, VISTA or Windows 7 and and transfer things that way from a modern PC to this DOS machine.
Here is the rear of the machine and as you can see it has all the standard ports as well as a PS/2 port for mouse and keyboard which is very convenient since I don’t have to bother with an AT keyboard or AT > PS/2 adapter. Also this PC has 2 USB ports but I haven’t messed around with them. I’ve read it is possible to install special USB DOS drivers but as of yet I haven’t played with that. It is useful to have them if i ever decide to put Windows 95/98 on this machine.
Pretty nice socket 7 Motherboard with 2 16 bit ISA slots, 5 PCI slots and an AGP slot. The AGP doesn’t get used under DOS but like I said before if I ever go Windows with it its there. As for the CPU I’m running the classic Pentium 133mhz which is mostly ideal. It will run a large amount of DOS games without issue and still has commendable speed as well as being super reliable.
I have a network card installed in one PCI slot but haven’t played around with it as of yet.
For Video I went with the S3 ViRGE/GX. The ViRGE/GX uses the mostly same 2D core as the S3 Trio64V+ so overall DOS comparability is still excellent. It also can do early 3D acceleration on games that support it and some games are “ViRGE enhanced” and use the S3D API. The GX variant is one of the faster versions of the card that still retains the ability to play older S3D games like DOS Terminal Velocity without graphical issues. Picture quality can vary between manufactures but the Nitro BIOS as seen here tend to give a good image quality. The 3d portion of the ViRGE really only comes into play if your running those games that support it but its still possibly one of the best all around cards for this fast DOS machine. My card has I believe 4MB or RAM, more then enough.
I also recently added a spare 3dfx Voodoo 1 card I had to take advantage of DOS Glide based games. Unlike the Voodoo card in my other fast Pentium based PC this is a Diamond manufactured card. Its basically exactly the same as the Orchid card in my other machine except this card uses a digital switch as opposed to mechanical so there’s no distinct “click” noise when the card becomes active.
Lastly for sound I went a slightly different route and decided to install a SB16 clone, the Audio Excel AV307. This is a ISA sound card that according to the box supports SB16/WSS/SB Pro/SB 2.0 as well as having a UART MPU-401 MIDI interface and wavetable that is free of the “hanging note bug” that plagues true Sound Blaster 16 cards. This card does not have true Yamaha FM chips though so FM synth is done via emulation which may sound off. I haven’t played with this card to much but It does seem to do a fair job and makes a decent alternative to the Sound Blaster 16 since the SB16 has issues with older Sound Blaster compatibility as well as issues with its MIDI ports.
BUT, if you want true Yamaha FM synth and really want to stay with Sound Blaster those are still a great choice. I recently was having some odd issues with this sound card so I stuck in CT1470 SB16. This is a very early SB16 card and one of the few models that does not have an issue with the “hanging note” bug. It is a noisy card but I haven’t had any issues with it.
Benchmarks
Pentium 133mhz, 128MB SDRAM, 512kb L2 cache, 4mb Virge PCI
3dBench – 87.2 FPS
PCPBench – 34.1 FPS
DOOM – 49.73 FPS
Quake – 28.8 FPS
Landmark 2.0 – cpu – 771 fpu – 2259 video – 10922
ancientelectronics 